Right now the same confident kids always end up as line leader or messenger, and the quieter ones never get a turn at the jobs they want. I've tried a job chart that rotates weekly, but it takes forever to update and the kids argue about who is next. I've also tried letting them volunteer, which just means the same few hands go up every time.
What has worked better for us is making the assignment random and visible, so everyone can see it is fair. We put all the jobs on a wheel — line leader, board cleaner, book monitor, plant waterer, door holder — and spin for each job at the start of the week. If a student already had a job that week, we remove them and spin again, so the jobs spread around. It takes about two minutes, and the kids actually look forward to the spin. We also use the same wheel for small rewards, like who picks the Friday read-aloud book. Lately we've been using a free classroom jobs wheel for this: https://thewheelpickers.com/classroom-jobs-wheel/ — you just add the jobs and spin, no sign-up.
How do you handle it? Do you rotate on a fixed schedule, let kids apply for jobs, or use some kind of draw? And how do you make sure the less popular jobs, like tidying up, still get done happily? Thanks!
What has actually worked for you? I've tried popsicle sticks in a cup, going around in seating order, and just picking names from a list, but each one had a downside — sticks get lost, seating order is too predictable, and picking from a list always feels a bit personal, like I chose that student.
One thing that made a real difference for us was making the pick visible and removing the name after each turn, so everyone gets one turn before anyone repeats. We also give a few seconds of think time and a pass option for anyone who freezes, which takes a lot of the fear out of it. Lately I've been using a free classroom wheel of names for this — you paste in the class list and spin: https://thewheelpickers.com/classroom-wheel-of-names/ — the whole class watches the spin, so nobody feels singled out, and letting a student spin for the next reader has actually become a little ritual they enjoy.
How do you balance fairness with kindness here? Do you use think-pair-share first, a pass card, or something else entirely? I'd really appreciate any routines that have worked in your room. Thanks!
I have always ...See MoreKeeping track of assignments, teaching personal responsibility and intrinsic motivation are always a key component of a Middle School setting. I have found over the years that while I can work towards these goals with my students at school, it seems to be the parents who ultimately get in the way of any progress being made.
I have always believed that Middle School is the time to "stop holing their hands" and really let them fail if you have to (it's a safer environment to fail than High School at least). While I keep my homework listed in the same spot in my room each day as well as on my class website, I just received an email from a parent who insisted that I must also post the homework on our schools grading system (it's a bigger hassle than it's worth) since their student just "won't" use their agenda. And that I must not count their child's last assignment as "late" since I didn't post it to this site.
How can you get parents to understand that it their child's responsibility to know the assigned work for the day and to figure out a system that works for their child--not their parents?
What mad...See MoreOne thing that has helped us with this is giving students real, rotating classroom jobs — not just the fun ones, but the everyday ones like materials manager, agenda checker, and tidy-up lead. When a job is actually theirs for the week, they start to own it, and it takes some of the pressure off chasing every missing assignment.
What made it work for us was making the rotation visible and fair. We spin a wheel to assign the jobs each week, so the same confident kids aren't always volunteering and no one feels singled out. Everyone gets a turn at the jobs they like and the ones they don't, which is kind of the point — responsibility isn't only doing what you enjoy.
It has helped the jobs feel like part of the classroom routine rather than another thing to manage, and the students remind each other about their jobs, which helps with that ownership you describe, Beccah.
Samantha MMolly, yes I do this because of my position. I have worked at this school for 7 years and it is definitely engrained in my teaching style. We recognize positive behavior with letters home, post cards home, or "Ask my why I got this sticker" stickers to encourage conversation at home but it is not to be used in the terms of "if you follow directions...See MoreMolly, yes I do this because of my position. I have worked at this school for 7 years and it is definitely engrained in my teaching style. We recognize positive behavior with letters home, post cards home, or "Ask my why I got this sticker" stickers to encourage conversation at home but it is not to be used in the terms of "if you follow directions today you get a sticker." I would love to know what it is like to be able to give my students a fun day or something to reward their behavior because as Ashley C stated, it is nice to recognize students always doing their jobs. I definitely feel like I focus much more on the re-direction of the bad behavior most of the time because that is where the most "restitution" comes into play. On the other hand, I like not having that extra layer of tracking (selfishly) to see who's class gets the reward and who's does not. When we do fun things, we call it "Spontaneous Celebrations" but with this it is not to be worded "because you did this we are doing this" and all students should participate not matter their behavior. It can be frustrating at times and at other times it is nice. It's difficult to explain. The other thing is there are multiple trainings on this method and trainers are practically obsolete. So when most of the staff doesn't have all of the training (like myself) it can be very difficult to use. There is a lot of language usage that needs to be universal and it can be successful when implemented universally the same way.
One thing that has worked well for us is making classroom jobs part of the recognition itself, rather than handing out prizes. Every student gets a turn at jobs like line leader, materials manager, or board helper, and the jobs rotate on a set schedule so nobody feels left out or like the same few kids always get picked. Because the job itself is the recognition — a responsibility, not a treat — it fits really well with a restitution mindset: students earn trust by contributing to the classroom, not by collecting things.
The fairness part matters a lot, though. The moment kids suspect the teacher is picking favorites, the whole system loses credibility. That is why we started using a random wheel to assign the jobs each week — everyone can see the spin, so it is clearly chance, not favoritism. If it helps, we put together a free classroom jobs wheel over at The Wheel Pickers that you can load with your own class jobs and spin to pick who does what: https://thewheelpickers.com/classroom-jobs-wheel/
It keeps the rotation honest, and the kids actually get excited about the spin itself. Hope that helps — and good luck blending PBIS with restitution, that is a tricky balance!
I'm currently studying SRL and I have found it to help shift my perspective on student learning. There are a plethora of posts on teacher forums asking for help with behaviour issues with "difficult" children, and yet very few make links to SRL and helping students regulate their behaviour. And yet, the research is quite clear; developing self-regu...See MoreI'm currently studying SRL and I have found it to help shift my perspective on student learning. There are a plethora of posts on teacher forums asking for help with behaviour issues with "difficult" children, and yet very few make links to SRL and helping students regulate their behaviour. And yet, the research is quite clear; developing self-regulated learning skills in students can and will help increase self-efficacy and increase achievement, thereby decreasing behaviour issues (Zimmerman, 2002)). Stuart Shanker discusses the link between behaviour and self-regulated learning at length on the website Self-Reg.ca and shares his method (The Shanker Method) for equipping students with the tools and knowledge of the processes that will help them move through stress and to self-regulation (Shanker, 2017). The perspective with self-regulated learning shifts from focusing on the student's undesirable behaviour to understanding the "why". By identifying the why behind the behaviour, and teaching the child the processes to move through it, we move from trying to regulate the child to empowering the child with the tools needed to self-regulate, "The Self-Reg educator or parent seeks to understand, rather than manage a child's behaviour" (Shanker, 2019). Further, Alderman and Macdonald state, in A Self-Regulatory Approach to Classroom Management: Empowering Students and Teachers, that "development of motivation and self-regulated learning skills can take classroom management beyond the role of maintaining order in the classroom to empower students and teachers for lifetime learning". Instead of trying to control the child through SRL we can empower the child to control their own thoughts and processes. Self-regulated learning not only improves classroom management it nurtures life-long learners equipped with the tools to navigate an increasingly stressful world.
The application is called Class Updates and work...See More I'm a college professor and President of an educational technology startup that helps to improve student learning and retention in the classroom. If you're passionate about education like I am then hopefully you will be glad to give me feedback and help with case studies in your classroom.
The application is called Class Updates and works like this:
We help connect students and teachers with instant push notifications so students never have to worry about forgetting a presentation being due or class being canceled. All the teacher has to do is sign up on the application and create a class for their relevant school and tell their students to sign up. Once signed up they will receive instant notifications right to their phone as soon as it is sent.
We've also built a calendar function so students can track all of their classes and future notifications in one place.
Screenshots of the app… (URLs of the images are here:
If you would like to download the application the links are below and I appreciate the discussion on the application and how we can help improve the learning environment for the students while saving faculty time.
First, I make sure students understand my expectations and that I am firm with them. My rules: 1. Respect me, the classroom, and each other. 2. Use materials responsibly. These are two concepts that are taught throughout our school, which means students are familiar with being respectful and responsible. If problems arise, I strive for immediate follow through. This can be anything from having a small discussion between the student and I or all the way up to a meeting with the principal. It all depends on the situation.
My second part of classroom management revolves around ensuring my students know they are cared for. They know I want them to succeed. I do not want them to have difficulties in class and they need to know that I am here for them. We build mutual respect and can work together to solve recurring issues they may experience in my classroom. This also includes having a fresh start with each class. I do not bring up past bad experiences with students. I am sure they remember them just fine on their own. My job is to continue working towards success, not dwell on the past.
LindaSuzanne Capek Tingley is a veteran teacher who says there are classroom management techniques, such as striking bargains with students, that may seem counterintuitive but actually work. Google her article: "5 Classroom Management Tips That Seem Counterintuitive." I agree with her--creative negotiation always worked well for me!